Mold Making Materials β Tool Steel Grades, Hardness & Selection Guide
Table of Contents
Table of Contents
- The Snapshot
- What Mold Material Actually Decides
- The Grade Ladder: P20 to S136
- Matching Steel to Resin and Part
- Where Each Material Sits in the Mold
- Heat Treatment, Nitriding and Coating
- Polish and Texture Requirements
- Aluminium and Copper Alloys for Bridge Tooling
- Cost and Lead-Time Trade-offs
- A Specification Template for Mold Steel Purchasing
- Seven Failure Modes and Their Fixes
- FAQ
- Sources
The Snapshot
- Prehardened P20 / 1.2311 at 28β32 HRC is the cheapest general-purpose plastic mold steel and typically delivers 200,000β300,000 shots before abrasion at gates and parting lines becomes a flash problem.
- 718H / 1.2738 at 33β37 HRC adds nickel for toughness in large cores; H13 / 1.2344 at 48β52 HRC after vacuum hardening and double tempering holds tolerance beyond 1,000,000 shots where P20 fails at 200,000β300,000.
- S136 / 1.2083, a 13% chromium stainless grade hardened to 48β52 HRC, reaches mirror polish of Ra β€0.025 Β΅m (VDI 0β3) and is effectively mandatory for PVC, halogenated flame-retardant resins and POM.
- Four questions decide the grade, in this order: corrosion, abrasion, surface grade, expected shots β price and machinability come after those four, not before.
- Most mold cost problems come from specifying one grade for the whole tool: cavity inserts, base, slides, manifold and ejector components normally want three to five different materials.
What Mold Material Actually Decides
Material choice is usually discussed as a durability question. In practice it decides five things at once, and the second and third are the ones that cause the most rework.
Life. Hardness, carbide content and toughness set how many cycles a cavity survives before wear at the gate, the parting line and the ejector land changes the part. This is the only dimension most buyers consider, and it is the one the steel salesman leads with.
Finish ceiling. A polish grade is a material property before it is a polishing skill. Inclusions and sulphur content cap how mirror-bright a surface can become, and no amount of polishing time converts a dirty steel into an optical cavity. Clean, low-sulphur grades β ESR or VAR where the specification demands it β are what make SPI A1 achievable on a lens or a lamp cover.
Corrosion behaviour. Resins are not neutral. PVC releases hydrogen chloride, halogenated flame retardants release acidic species, and POM releases formaldehyde at melt temperature. On unprotected tool steel this shows up as pitting in cooling channels and along parting surfaces, usually at the waterline first, and it progresses faster than most maintenance programmes expect.
Thermal behaviour. Conductivity and thermal fatigue resistance affect both cycle time and crack initiation. Aluminium and copper alloys move heat fast, which shortens cycles on thick parts; hardened tool steels resist thermal cycling but conduct slowly. High mould temperature resins such as PEEK and PPS put the steel into a thermal fatigue regime where stress relief during build matters as much as the grade.
Repairability. A cracked core in a through-hardened H13 insert can be welded and re-machined. The same crack in a large prehardened block may require replacing the insert, because welding a prehardened block introduces a hardness discontinuity that shows up as a witness line on the part. Repair strategy belongs in the material decision, not in the maintenance budget.
The Grade Ladder: P20 to S136
These are the grades that cover the overwhelming majority of plastic injection molds. Hardness values below are delivery or post-hardening values as commonly supplied and are consistent across published mill data.
| Grade (AISI / DIN) | Delivery hardness | Toughness | Polish capability | Relative material cost | Typical role |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| P20 / 1.2311 | 28β32 HRC prehardened | Moderate | Good, not optical | Baseline (lowest) | Medium-run cavities and cores, simple inserts |
| 718H / 1.2738 | 33β37 HRC prehardened | Good | Good to high | Small uplift | Large cores, deep cavities, thick sections |
| NAK80 | 37β41 HRC prehardened | Moderate | Very high (mirror) | Uplift | Small appearance inserts, precision cores |
| H13 / 1.2344 | 48β52 HRC after hardening + double temper | High | Moderate | Uplift plus heat treatment | Abrasive and glass-filled resins, long-run cavities |
| S136 / 1.2083 | 48β52 HRC hardened | Moderate-high | Highest (Ra β€0.025 Β΅m) | High | Corrosive resins, optical and medical parts |
| S7 | 54β58 HRC hardened | Very high (shock) | Moderate | High | Slides, lifters, shock-loaded cores |
| 420 stainless | 48β52 HRC | Moderate | High | Moderate-high | Food contact, light corrosion work |
Some notes that matter more than the table:
P20 and 718H are cousins, not equivalents. Both are prehardened and both machine without a post-hardening step, but 718H carries a deliberate nickel addition that raises hardness and through-thickness consistency. That hardness comes with a machining penalty: nickel makes the steel gummier, so CNC feed rates drop slightly and insert wear rises. Shops that treat 718H as βP20 but harderβ and keep P20 cutting parameters will burn tools and blame the steel.
H13 is a hot-work grade used cold. Its value in a plastic mold is vanadium carbide for abrasion resistance plus enough chromium (around 5%) for partial corrosion resistance and stability at elevated mould temperatures. It is the default answer for glass-filled engineering resins and for high-temperature processing, and it is a poor answer for optical parts because polishability is not its strength.
S136 solves a chemistry problem, not a hardness problem. The 13% chromium is there because PVC and halogenated FR resins attack ordinary steel. It also happens to be the most polishable standard mold grade, which is why optical and medical parts land on it even when the resin is benign. The trade is cost and a storage discipline: stainless mold steel still rusts if it sits wet between trials.
NAK80 is the appearance compromise. Prehardened at 37β41 HRC and mirror-polishable, it lets a small appearance insert reach a high polish without a hardening cycle that risks distortion. It is not an abrasion grade and should not be used where glass-filled resin runs across a gate.
S7 is an action grade. Slides, lifters and cores that see impact loads benefit from shock resistance rather than pure hardness; specifying S7 for a static cavity wastes money, and specifying P20 for a slide that cycles a million times invites a fatigue crack.
Matching Steel to Resin and Part
The resin map is the fastest route to a defensible specification. It is also where the most expensive mistakes happen, because corrosion and abrasion failures appear months after the tool is accepted.
| Resin / part condition | Corrosion risk | Abrasion risk | Recommended cavity steel |
|---|---|---|---|
| PVC, CPVC, PVC compounds | High (HCl release) | Low | S136 or 420 stainless, plated cooling channels |
| Halogenated flame-retardant ABS/PC | High | Low-medium | S136 |
| POM / acetal | High (formaldehyde at melt temperature) | Low | S136 or hardened 420 |
| Glass-filled PA6/PA66, PBT, PPS, PPA | Low | High | H13 hardened, or S7 for shock zones |
| Mineral-filled PP/PA | Low | High | H13 |
| Clear PC, PMMA, COC/COP, light guides | Low | Low | S136, low-inclusion, ESR where available |
| Medical and food-contact parts | Medium | Low | S136 or 420 stainless, validated cleaning regime |
| PEEK, PPS, high-temperature resins | Low | Medium | H13, manifold in H13 or 1.2343 |
| Large deep cores, thick sections | Low | Low-medium | 718H / 1.2738 |
| Bridge and prototype tooling | Low | Low | P20 or aluminium 6061/7075 |
| Million-shot commodity parts | Low | Medium | H13 with nitrided wear surfaces |
Two rules follow. First, corrosion protection must extend to the cooling circuit, not just the cavity β a stainless cavity fed by an unprotected channel pits from the water side. Second, abrasion protection belongs at the gate first: the gate is where melt velocity peaks, and an H13 cavity with a P20 gate insert is a wear experiment with a predictable outcome.
Where Each Material Sits in the Mold
A mold is not one block of steel. Typical architecture uses different grades by function, and this is where a well-specified tool separates from a cheap one.
| Mold location | Typical material | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Cavity insert | P20, 718H, H13, S136 or NAK80 depending on resin and life | Direct contact with resin; drives surface and wear |
| Core insert | 718H, H13, S136 | Often deeper and more highly loaded than the cavity |
| Mold base / frame | 1045 / S50C or 1.2311 | Structural only; no need for premium grade |
| Slides and lifters | S7 or nitrided H13 | Impact and sliding wear |
| Hot runner manifold | H13 or 1.2343 | Thermal cycling and pressure |
| Nozzle tips and gate inserts | H13, S136, or beryllium copper where heat control dominates | Wear at the highest-velocity point |
| Ejector pins and sleeves | Standard hardened components | Wear part; cheap to replace, expensive to lose |
| Guide pins and bushings | Standard hardened components | Alignment and clearance control |
| Cooling inserts / baffles | Copper alloys or aluminium inserts where heat extraction dominates | Conductivity |
Two things follow from that layout. First, quoting βsteel gradeβ as a single line item hides where the money is: a tool with S136 cavity inserts, H13 slides and a 1045 base is a different product from one with H13 everywhere, and neither is wrong β they are answers to different life requirements. Second, replaceable wear parts should be specified as replaceable from the start. An ejector pin that costs a few dollars is not the problem; the production stop while someone measures it is.
Heat Treatment, Nitriding and Coating
Heat treatment is where prehardened and hardened grades diverge operationally.
Prehardened grades (P20, 718H, NAK80) arrive ready to machine. There is no hardening cycle after roughing, which means no dimensional shift and no risk of distortion in a large block. The trade is a hardness ceiling: these grades cannot be pushed past roughly 40 HRC, and they cannot be re-hardened after weld repair without a full heat treatment that will move the geometry.
Hardened grades (H13, S136, S7, 420) are usually rough machined, stress relieved, vacuum hardened, double or triple tempered, then finish machined or EDMβd. The sequencing matters: hardening after finish machining is a distortion risk, and finish machining after hardening costs more in tool wear. Suppliers who harden first and then complain about EDM time are telling you the process plan was wrong at kickoff.
Nitriding adds a hard case β typically in the 0.1β0.3 mm range with surface hardness in the 65β70 HRC region depending on process β which raises wear resistance at gate areas, parting lines and slide surfaces without changing the core toughness. It is also the routine remedy when surface hardness has dropped during service, which is why re-nitriding appears in maintenance intervals on high-cycle tools.
PVD and DLC coating deposits an ultra-thin hard layer that reduces sticking, improves wear resistance against glass-filled resins and can improve heat transfer characteristics at the surface. Coating is applied after final polishing, and its value is functional: a DLC layer on a glass-filled PBT cavity is a life decision, and a decorative coating over a damaged polish hides nothing.
Stress relief is the least glamorous and most under-specified step. Large blocks and deep cavities accumulate residual stress through rough machining; stress relief before finish machining is what prevents a core from moving three months into production. It belongs on the purchase order as an explicit operation, not as an assumption.
Polish and Texture Requirements
Surface requirements are written in grades, and the grade must be compatible with the steel.
| Grade family | Typical range | Application | Material implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| VDI 3400 texture | VDI 12 (fine) to VDI 45 (coarse) | Interior grains, matte and semi-gloss surfaces | Etch response must be even; deep grains need etch stock |
| SPI polish | SPI D3 (matte) through SPI A1 (super mirror) | Exterior gloss parts, lenses, light guides | A1 requires low-inclusion, low-sulphur steel, ESR/VAR if specified |
| Mirror for optical | Ra β€0.025 Β΅m | Lenses, light pipes, transparent covers | S136 or NAK80 territory; cleanliness is the limit |
Three practical rules:
- Specify the grade on the drawing and in the mold technical agreement. βHigh glossβ is not measurable, SPI A1 is. The same applies to texture: a grain standard plus a gloss target plus a colour master, not a photograph.
- Order the steel for the finish you specified. A texture that requires deep etching needs more stock and a steel that etches uniformly; a mirror finish needs a steel without inclusions. Upgrading steel later to fix polish defects costs more than specifying it correctly once.
- Map texture onto the flow analysis. Gloss on a textured surface depends on local shear history, and a texture boundary landing on a visible radius will read as an edge on the part.
For adjacent reading, our guide on injection molding materials covers the resin side of the same decision, and the plastic material selection guide covers property trade-offs.
Aluminium and Copper Alloys for Bridge Tooling
Aluminium is not a poor manβs steel; it is a different answer to a different question.
Aluminium 6061 and 7075 machine several times faster than tool steel, conduct heat well and cost far less per block for a given size. In bridge and prototype tooling that means parts in days rather than weeks, which matters when a design is still moving. The limits are equally clear: lower wear resistance, lower strength at elevated temperature, and a hardness that will not survive abrasive resins or high cycles. Aluminium tooling is normally specified for hundreds to low thousands of shots, and its cavity geometry and gate layout are often designed to be superseded by a steel tool rather than upgraded into one.
Beryllium copper (BeCu) inserts solve hot-spot problems. Where a part has a thick section, a deep boss or a core that cannot be cooled with water close enough to the surface, a BeCu insert pulls heat out of the region and shortens the cycle that would otherwise be set by that hot spot. BeCu is also used for gate inserts where local heat control matters. It is soft relative to tool steel, so it is used where thermal performance outweighs wear life, and it requires its own handling discipline because beryllium-bearing dust is a health hazard in machining.
Copper alloys as core pins and baffles occasionally replace steel where heat extraction dominates and mechanical load is low. The engineering question is always the same: is this location failing because of wear or because of heat? Wear is answered with steel, heat with conductivity.
Cost and Lead-Time Trade-offs
Mold steel cost is easy to compare per kilogram and misleading to compare per tool, because the cheap grade often ends up costing more through maintenance, rework and lost output.
| Decision | Up-front effect | Life-cycle effect | When it pays |
|---|---|---|---|
| P20 instead of H13 | Lower steel and no hardening cost | Wear at gate and parting line; flash appears earlier | Low-shot, non-abrasive work |
| H13 instead of P20 | Higher steel plus heat treatment and more EDM | Multiplies life on abrasive resins; tolerates more cycles | Glass-filled or million-shot programmes |
| S136 instead of H13 | Higher material cost | Avoids corrosion pitting; enables optical polish | PVC, halogenated FR, optical and medical |
| NAK80 for small appearance inserts | Moderate uplift | Avoids post-hardening distortion risk | Precision inserts where geometry is already final |
| Prehardened block instead of insert strategy | Lower machining cost initially | Whole block scrapped if one cavity fails | Simple, low-run tools only |
| Stress relief operation added | Small cost and a day in the schedule | Prevents dimensional drift in service | Any large block or deep cavity |
| DLC/PVD coating | Coating cost plus a process step | Reduces sticking and glass-fibre wear | Abrasive resins, high-release-demand parts |
Lead time follows the same logic. Prehardened grades are generally stocked and machine immediately. Hardened grades add a heat treatment cycle that is measured in days and is subject to furnace scheduling. S136 and ESR-quality steels are less commonly stocked. Long-lead special grades can dominate a tool schedule, which is why steel procurement is the first line of any honest lead-time calculation.
A costing rule of thumb worth using in reviews: compare total cost of ownership across the expected shot count, not the steel invoice. Two hundred thousand extra shots of life on a part with meaningful margin usually pays for a grade upgrade several times over, and a corrosion failure in a cooling circuit costs more than the entire stainless upgrade.
A Specification Template for Mold Steel Purchasing
Purchasing language is where good intentions become a tool. A mold steel specification that survives audit answers these questions in writing:
- Grade and standard β AISI and DIN designation both, with the mill certificate required.
- Delivery condition and hardness β prehardened with a stated HRC range, or annealed for post-hardening.
- Cleanliness requirement β sulphur level, ESR/VAR requirement, inclusion rating where the surface grade demands it.
- Size and stock allowance β block dimensions with machining and etch stock, and the rule used to derive it.
- Heat treatment sequence β who hardens, to what hardness, with how many tempers, and where stress relief sits in the process.
- Surface treatment β nitriding specification, coating type and thickness, and the polishing step that must precede coating.
- Verification β hardness test locations and method, ultrasonic inspection for large blocks, dimensional report on the finished insert.
- Traceability β heat number against the mill certificate, recorded on the tool documentation package.
- Replaceable-part strategy β which inserts are designed as spare parts and what the lead time is for a replacement.
- Repair policy β which components may be welded, with what procedure and post-weld treatment.
Molditquick issues this specification as part of the mold making service scope, so the steel decision, the heat treatment sequence and the surface grade are locked before machining starts rather than negotiated after a trial failure. If your programme needs an independent review of an existing specification, the quote flow can carry it.
Seven Failure Modes and Their Fixes
| Failure | Mechanism | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Galling on slides and lifters | Adhesive wear between similar steels under load | Dissimilar hardness, nitriding, lubrication path, S7 or nitrided H13 |
| Stress corrosion cracking in cooling channels | Corrosive resin plus residual tensile stress plus water chemistry | S136 cavity, channel plating, water treatment, stress relief |
| Polishing pits on an appearance cavity | Non-metallic inclusions exposed by polishing | Low-sulphur/ESR steel, re-specify rather than over-polish |
| Cracking at sharp internal corners | Stress concentration under thermal cycling | Corner radii, stress relief, avoid hardening after sharp-corner EDM without tempering |
| Hot runner manifold warp | Thermal gradient across the manifold | H13 or 1.2343 manifold, controlled warm-up, correct heater zoning |
| Gate wear and flash | Abrasive melt at peak velocity on soft steel | H13 or carbide gate insert, replaceable gate design |
| Parting-line sink after long runs | Base steel compression and wear at the shut-off | Hardened parting surfaces, insert strategy for the shut-off faces |
Each of these is cheaper to prevent at the specification stage than to repair after acceptance, which is the whole argument for spending engineering time on material selection rather than on price negotiation.
FAQ
Which mold steel is best for injection molds?
There is no single best grade, because the answer depends on the resin and the required life. P20 or 718H suits medium-run, non-abrasive work; H13 suits glass-filled and long-run cavities; S136 suits corrosive resins and optical parts; NAK80 suits small prehardened appearance inserts; S7 suits slides and shock-loaded cores.
What is the difference between P20 and 718H?
718H is effectively P20 with a nickel addition, delivered harder (33β37 HRC versus 28β32 HRC) and with better through-thickness consistency for large blocks. It machines slightly harder because nickel makes the steel gummier, so cutting parameters must be adjusted.
When do I need S136 instead of H13?
When corrosion, not abrasion, is the risk: PVC, halogenated flame-retardant resins, and POM which releases formaldehyde at melt temperature. S136 is also the choice for optical and medical parts because of its polishability to Ra β€0.025 Β΅m. H13 remains the better answer for abrasive glass-filled resins.
Why does my mold steel need stress relief?
Rough machining leaves residual stress in large blocks and deep cavities. Without stress relief before finish machining, that stress releases during production and the cavity moves, which shows up as dimensional drift and parting-line mismatch months after acceptance.
Is aluminium tooling good enough for production?
For low volumes, prototypes and bridge tooling, yes β aluminium machines fast, conducts heat well and costs less per block. It is not a production answer for abrasive resins or high shot counts, because wear resistance and elevated-temperature strength are limited.
What does nitriding actually do for a mold?
It creates a hard case roughly 0.1β0.3 mm deep with surface hardness in the region of 65β70 HRC, improving wear resistance at gates, parting lines and slides without changing core toughness. It is also the standard remedy when surface hardness drops during service.
How much does mold steel cost relative to the whole tool?
Steel, hot runner and standard components typically account for roughly 35β45% of a quoted mold, with machining and manufacturing another 35β45%. Steel grade changes therefore move the quote meaningfully, but so does cavity count and texture area.
Can I mix steel grades in one mold?
You should. Cavity inserts in the grade the resin demands, base in 1045 or 1.2311, slides in S7 or nitrided H13, manifold in H13 β a single-grade tool is usually either over-specified in the base or under-specified at the gate.
What hardness should an injection mold cavity be?
Prehardened cavities run 28β41 HRC depending on grade (P20, 718H, NAK80); hardened cavities run 48β58 HRC (H13, S136, S7). The choice follows resin abrasion, expected shots and whether post-hardening distortion is acceptable for the geometry.
Does steel grade affect cycle time?
Indirectly, yes. Thermal conductivity differs between grades and between steel and copper alloys, and heat extraction at hot spots often sets the cycle. Where a thick section controls the cycle, a copper alloy insert can shorten it more than any process tuning.
What is ESR steel and do I need it?
ESR (electro-slag remelted) steel has lower inclusion content and more uniform structure than conventionally melted steel, which improves polishability and toughness. It matters for optical cavities, large blocks and high-polish Class-A surfaces; it is unnecessary cost for a non-cosmetic structural part.
How do I verify the steel actually supplied?
Require the mill certificate with the heat number, verify hardness at defined locations on the finished insert, request ultrasonic inspection for large blocks, and record the heat number in the tool documentation package so a later failure can be traced to a specific heat.
Sources
- LongTeam, Injection Mold Steel Selection Guide: P20, H13, S136 and NAK80 β https://www.longteamtw.com/blog/injection-mold-steel-selection-guide
- ASTM Steel, Hardness difference: 1.2311 vs P20 vs 1.2738 plastic mold steel β https://www.astmsteel.com/steel-knowledge/hardness-difference-1-2311-p20-1-2738-plastic-mold-steel
- Promisteel, P20 tool steel vs 718H: plastic mold steel selection β https://www.promisteel.com/info/p20-tool-steel-v-718h-plastic-mold-steel-guide-103436036.html
- Asia Tools, P20 vs 718 mold steel β https://www.asiatools.net/news/blog/p20-vs-718-mold-steel-what-is-the-difference
- Weilan Manufacturing, Selecting durable tool steel for long-life plastic injection molds β https://weilan-mfg.com/blogs/news/tool-steel-plastic-injection-molds-guide
- First Mold, Mold making materials library β https://firstmold.com/materials/mold-making-materials/
- Standards referenced by name: AISI/SAE and DIN 1.2311 / 1.2738 / 1.2344 / 1.2083, ISO 4957, SPI mold classification, SPI/VDI surface grades, ISO 294-4, UL 94.
NEXT STEP
Ready to Start Your Project?
Send us your requirements β our team responds within 24 hours. Pricing and a realistic lead time come with the reply.
Written by
Ray ChanExport Brand Manager Β· Injection Molding, Mold Making & DFM. Ray helps global importers and integrators source factory-direct plastic parts and tooling.